Court of Appeals Opinions

Format: 08/20/2014
Format: 08/20/2014
Jonthan Hyler v. Charles Traughber, Chairman Tennessee Board of Paroles, et al.
01A01-9610-CH-00482
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Henry F. Todd
Trial Court Judge: Chancellor Irvin H. Kilcrease, Jr.

The captioned petitioner has appealed from the judgment of the Trial Court dismissing his petition for certiorari from the action of the Board of Paroles denying hisapplication for parole from the custody of the Department of Correction.

Davidson County Court of Appeals 02/07/97
Tina R. Guffey vs. Wenco of Shelbyville, Inc., d/b/a Wendy's Restaurant - Concurring
01A01-9609-CV-00400
Authoring Judge: Judge Henry F. Todd
Trial Court Judge: Judge Lee Russell

This is a “slip and fall case” in which the jury awarded $173,250, and the defendant appealed.

Bedford County Court of Appeals 02/07/97
Joe Larry Turnbo vs. Brenda Jane (Thompson) Turnbo
01A01-9307-CH-00314
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge Henry F. Todd
Trial Court Judge:

The defendant/appellee has filed a respectful petition to rehear. It appears that a rehearing is appropriate, and same is hereby granted.

Court of Appeals 02/07/97
Roscoe W. Fields, Sr., v. Bobby Ray McGee and Lillian Bean
03A01-9609-CV-00296
Authoring Judge: Senior Judge William H. Inman
Trial Court Judge:

Mr. Fields says that Joe Torrence, the Circuit Court Clerk of Davidson County, charged him an excessive fee for a certified copy of a traffic citation, for which he attempted to seek redress in General Sessions Court of Knox County. He says that the Judge of the Knox County General Sessions Court and the Clerk thereof refused to allow him to file his warrant, whereupon he attempted to file it in Davidson County, and was rebuffed; he thereupon attempted to file a redressing action in the Davidson Chancery Court, and was again rebuffed. He returned to Knox County, and filed this pro se action for damages against Judge McGee and Clerk Bean, asserting that they violated his civil rights under 42 U. S. C. §1983, by refusing to allow him to file the action against Clerk Torrence. The trial judge directed a verdict for the defendants at the close of the plaintiff’s case, holding that he had failed to make out a prima facie case.

Knox County Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Richard E. Perry, and wife, Tamelia Perry, v. Terry Flatford and wife, Teresa Flatford, Brenda Dye, Gordon White, Remax Preferred Properties, Inc., David Snelson, Beverly V. McMahan, Crossroads Realty, et al.
03A01-9609-CH-00305
Authoring Judge: Senior Judge William H. Inman
Trial Court Judge:

This is an action for damages allegedly sustained by the plaintiffs as a result  of misrepresentations made to them in their purchase of a residence.

Union County Court of Appeals 02/05/97
State of Tennessee, Department of Human Services v. Charlene Avery Fountain
03A01-9601-JV-00021
Authoring Judge: Per Curiam
Trial Court Judge:

This appeal came on to be heard upon the record from the Juvenile Court of Knox County and briefs filed on behalf of the respective parties. Upon consideration thereof, this court is of the opinion that there is no reversible error in the trial court’s judgment.

Knox County Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Aetna Insurance Company and Church of God of Prophecy, v. Little Giant Mfg. Co., Inc. and Edwin L. Wiegand Division of Emerson Electric Company
03A01-9601-CV-00024
Authoring Judge:
Trial Court Judge: Senior Judge William H. Inman

This complaint was filed by the Church of God of Prophecy against the Little Giant Mfg. Co. and Kick-Shaw, Inc., alleging that its property was destroyed by fire caused by a defective water heater manufactured by Little Giant and sold to the plaintiff by Kick-Shaw, Inc. Various defenses were interposed by the defendants, none of which is relevant to the issue before us. Thereafter, the complaint was repeatedly amended; new parties came and went; and, in its present posture, the plaintiffs are Aetna Insurance Company and Church of God of Prophecy and the defendants are Little Giant Mfg. Co., Inc. and Emerson Electric Company.

Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Erma Hardesty and Jim Hardesty, v. Service Merchandise Company, Inc.
02A01-9510-CV-00235
Authoring Judge: Judge Paul G. Summers
Trial Court Judge:

The majority holds that the plaintiff cannot establish constructive notice. I am constrained to agree. However, I invite our Supreme Court to revisit this area of law.

Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Erma Hardesty and Jim Hardesty v. Service Merchandise Company, Inc.
02A01-9510-CV-00235
Authoring Judge: Judge David R. Farmer
Trial Court Judge: Judge Robert A. Lanier

This appeal is taken from the trial court’s order of June 7, 1995, granting summary judgment in favor of Defendant Service Merchandise Company, Inc. (hereinafter, “Service Merchandise”). Specifically, the trial court found that there was no proof of a dangerous condition created by Service Merchandise and no proof that Service Merchandise had either actual or constructive notice that a dangerous condition existed. Upon consideration of the record before us, the trial court’s order is affirmed.

Shelby County Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Amanda Carol Croslin and Phyllis Croslin Baker, v. Danny Keith Croslin, wife Betty Jean Croslin and Stanley Gardner Haskins
01A01-9607-CV-00297
Authoring Judge: Presiding Judge W. Frank Crawford
Trial Court Judge: Judge John A. Turnbull

This is an adoption case. Petitioners, Amanda Croslin and Phyllis Croslin Baker, the adoptive child’s mother and maternal grandmother respectively, filed a petition to set aside the adoption of the child, Danna Elisabeth Croslin, by the maternal grandfather, Danny Keith Croslin, and his wife, Betty Jean Croslin. Also named as a defendant in the petition is Stanley Gardner Haskins, the adoptive child’s natural father. From the order of the trial court nullifying and setting aside the adoption, Danny Keith Croslin has appealed. Mr. Haskins did not file any pleading in the trial court and is not a party to this appeal.

Smith County Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Mohammad Al-Haddad v. Walter Ritter and Wife, Helma Ritter
01A01-9608-CV-00369
Authoring Judge: Judge Ben H. Cantrell
Trial Court Judge: Judge Donald P. Harris

Pursuant to Rule 11, Tenn. R. Civ. P., the trial court sanctioned the appellants and their attorneys. The appellants argue on appeal that they cannot be sanctioned under Rule 11 because they did not sign the offending pleading and that the facts do not establish a violation of the rule. We hold that a party may be sanctioned under Rule 11 without actually signing the pleadings, but we find that the facts of this case do not justify a Rule 11 sanction and that the proof fails to show any expenses incurred as a result of the alleged violation. Therefore we reverse the judgment against the appellants for sanctions.

Williamson County Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Mavis A. Combs, v. The Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County, and the Civil Service Commission
01A01-9608-CH-00385
Authoring Judge: Judge Samuel L. Lewis
Trial Court Judge: Chancellor Ellen Hobbs Lyle

This is an appeal by petitioner/appellant, Mavis A. Combs, from the decision of the Davidson County Chancery Court upholding the decision of respondent/appellee, the Metropolitan Civil Service Commission (“the Commission”), to deny Ms. Combs in-line-of-duty injury leave. The facts out of which this matter arose are as follows.

Davidson County Court of Appeals 02/05/97
Barbara Gatlin, v. State of Tennessee, Department of Human Services, In the Matter of Felicia Gatlin, a child under the age of 18
01A01-9607-JV-00311
Authoring Judge: Judge Ben H. Cantrell
Trial Court Judge: Judge Andrew J. Shookhoff

The Juvenile Court of Davidson County terminated Barbara Gatlin’s parental rights respecting her ten year old daughter, Felicia. Because we find that the record does not contain clear and convincing evidence of abandonment, we reverse.

Davidson County Court of Appeals 02/05/97